Skip to content
Markets
Markets updating…
OddsGuru

OddsGuru knowledge libraryUS Open

US Open Underdog Picks: When the Long Shot Is Worth It

Back a US Open underdog when you can name a specific reason the price is too long. This guide covers the player profiles, format effects, price maths and stake sizing behind tennis underdog picks at Flushing Meadows.

J

By

Guides & Explainers · odds.guru

Published Updated 6 min read
US Open Underdog Picks: When the Long Shot Is Worth It
Strategy guideIntermediate

Key takeaways

  1. 1.Back a US Open underdog when you can name why the price is too long, not because the payout looks big.
  2. 2.A +400 price implies 20%. The bet adds value only if you rate the underdog's chances higher than that.
  3. 3.Best-of-three women's matches usually leave more room for upsets than men's best-of-five.
  4. 4.Set and game handicaps let you back a competitive underdog without needing the outright upset.
  5. 5.Many bettors keep single underdog stakes near 1-2% of bankroll, and outright long shots smaller still.

A US Open underdog is worth backing when you can name a specific reason the price is too long. That reason might be a game built for hard courts, strong form from the summer hard-court swing, or a matchup the ranking misses. If the only reason is that the payout looks big, most bettors are better off passing. Most underdogs lose, so the price has to pay enough to cover those losses.

This guide covers the tennis US Open at Flushing Meadows, not golf's U.S. Open. For the wider market picture, start with the US Open betting guide.

Which US Open underdogs are worth backing?

The ranking tells you how a player has done across a whole season on every surface. The US Open is played on one surface, at one point in the calendar. The gap between those two things is where underdog value usually comes from.

These are the profiles bettors commonly look for:

  • Hard-court players with a clay-hurt ranking. A player with a big serve and flat groundstrokes may have lost ranking points in the spring clay season. Their US Open price can then reflect that ranking more than their quality on hard courts.
  • Players rising through the summer hard-court swing. Results at the Canadian Open and Cincinnati are played on similar courts a few weeks before New York. Prices do not always catch up with a player who is trending upward.
  • Players returning on a protected ranking. A player coming back from injury can enter at a ranking well below their real level. Their early-round price may follow that number rather than their recent match quality.
  • Young players on their second or third Slam visit. Some bettors expect breakthroughs once the first-time nerves are gone. This is a pattern people watch for, not a proven rule, so treat it as a reason to look closer rather than a reason to bet.
Some bettors also rate players with a strong record on Arthur Ashe Stadium or in night matches. The samples are often small, so this works better as a tiebreaker than as the main reason for a bet. The night-session guide covers that angle.

How does the US Open format change underdog odds?

Match length is the biggest format factor. Men play best-of-five sets at the Slams and women play best-of-three. Over a longer match, the stronger player has more time to recover from a bad patch. As a result, men's Slam favourites usually win more reliably than favourites in shorter formats.

The women's draw has produced some of the most famous US Open long shots. In 2021, Emma Raducanu won the title as a qualifier, and Leylah Fernandez reached the final unseeded. In 2015, Roberta Vinci beat Serena Williams in the semi-finals. Upsets still happen in men's best-of-five matches too. In 2014, Kei Nishikori beat Novak Djokovic in one semi-final and Marin Cilic beat Roger Federer in the other, per Tennis365's ranking of the biggest upsets in tournament history.

These examples show that upsets happen. They do not show that backing underdogs blindly is profitable.

Two other format details matter:

  • Draw size. Both singles draws have 128 players and 32 seeds. Seeds therefore face unseeded players in the first two rounds, which is where most underdog spots appear. Our first-round upsets guide looks at why top seeds slip early.
  • Conditions. Heat, humidity and the switch between day and night sessions can change how fast the court plays. They can also affect how a tired favourite holds up. See how weather affects US Open betting.

How do sportsbooks price US Open underdogs?

Every price converts to an implied probability. An underdog bet only has value if you believe the player's real chance of winning is higher than the probability the price implies.

American priceImplied probabilityProfit on a $10 stake
+25028.6%$25
+40020.0%$40
+60014.3%$60
+15006.3%$150
+50002.0%$500

Implied probability = 100 ÷ (American price + 100). Sportsbooks build a margin into their prices, so the true break-even point sits slightly above these figures.

Here is a worked example. Suppose you rate an unseeded hard-court specialist at 25% to beat a seed. At 5.00, the price implies 20%, so on your numbers the bet has value. At 3.50, the price implies 28.6%, which is higher than your 25%, so the same player is no longer a value bet.

It is also worth checking whether the favourite's price is too short. Common examples include:

  • a top seed whose ranking was built mostly on clay
  • a former champion whose recent results are declining
  • a big name returning from a long layoff
Some bettors also believe American players in prime-time night matches get shorter prices because of home support. We have not seen data that confirms this, so treat it as something to check, not something to assume.

Which underdog markets go beyond the moneyline?

An underdog can be competitive without winning the match. Several markets pay out on that kind of result:

  • Set handicap. In best-of-five, +2.5 sets wins if the underdog takes at least one set, and +1.5 sets needs them to take two. In best-of-three, +1.5 sets wins if the underdog takes one set. These bets pay less than the moneyline but win more often.
  • Game handicap. A line such as +4.5 games covers a close loss.
  • Total games over. Close matches tend to run long, so the over can pay out if the underdog competes but still loses.
  • First-set winner. This suits an underdog who usually starts fast but tends to fade later in matches.
  • To reach a round. Backing a seeded player outside the top 10 to reach the second week can be an alternative to a long outright price.
The tennis prop bets guide explains how these lines are set.

How much should you stake on US Open underdogs?

Underdog betting means long losing runs, even when your reasoning is sound. A common starting point is 1-2% of bankroll for each single underdog bet. Outright long shots are often staked smaller, at around 0.25-0.5%. A 51.00 outright implies roughly a 2% chance of winning, so even a fairly priced bet like that loses about 49 times in 50.

Many bettors also spread their underdog bets across different quarters of the draw. That way, one quarter where all the favourites win does not wipe out the whole tournament. Others prefer to make fewer, larger bets on the matchups they have studied most closely. Both approaches can work if the stakes match your bankroll. The tennis value and bankroll guide covers sizing in more detail.

Passing is usually the better choice in these situations:

  • A big surface mismatch. A clay specialist facing a top hard-court player is often priced long for good reason.
  • Qualifiers with little recent main-draw experience. These players are sometimes long because they are genuinely outmatched.
  • Late rounds against in-form top players. Favourites who reach the second week are usually there because they are playing well.
  • No specific reason. If you cannot explain why the price is wrong, there is no evidence you have an advantage.
Compare current US Open tennis odds across betting platforms
Share:
J

Contributor

Guides & Explainers · odds.guru

View James's profile

James Okafor publishes educational guides and clear explainers for odds.guru.

Sportsbook guidesRegulationResponsible gambling

About this byline: James Okafor is an editorial pen name used by odds.guru for educational guides and explainers. Articles carrying this byline are approved by an accountable editor under our editorial standards. Read our editorial standards.

AI & editorial disclosure

OddsGuru may use AI tools to support research, drafting, editing, formatting, and production workflows. Every published article is reviewed and approved by an editor before publication. AI tools do not publish articles independently, and editorial responsibility remains with the OddsGuru team. Read our AI usage policy

Affiliate & risk disclosure

OddsGuru may earn a commission when readers visit partners through links on this page. Our news coverage is informational only and should not be treated as betting, financial, legal, or investment advice. Odds, prices, markets, availability, and eligibility can change. Always check the operator's terms and gamble responsibly. Affiliate disclosure · Responsible trading · Terms