NHL moneyline vs three way betting: What Counts?

A standard NHL moneyline backs a team to win the game, including overtime and any shootout. A three-way bet backs the home team, away team or tie after 60 minutes of regulation. Choose a team in that market and a regulation tie loses, even if your team wins later.

The choice depends on which result you want to back and whether the payout justifies its chance of happening. Our NHL betting guide explains the wider market menu; here, the distinction is when your bet stops counting.

What is the difference between NHL moneyline and three-way betting?

The standard moneyline follows the eventual winner; the three-way regulation market follows the score at the end of the third period. BettorEdge’s explanation of the hockey three-way moneyline identifies these settlement periods and the separate tie selection.

That gives the same team different winning conditions:

Settlement comparison follows the standard market definitions described by BettorEdge. Check the terms attached to your selection.

“Regulation line” and “60-minute line” are common labels for the three-way market. The word “moneyline” alone is less useful because it can appear in both market names.

• A full-game team selection can win through regulation or extra play.
• A three-way team selection needs that team ahead when regulation ends.
• A three-way tie selection needs equal scores at that moment.

A regulation win can be by one goal. It does not require the winning margin attached to a puck-line handicap, covered separately in our NHL puck line guide.

How do NHL moneyline and three-way payouts compare?

Calculate the payout from the quoted price, then check the result required to earn it. A larger potential return does not make two selections equivalent.

Consider these hypothetical prices, using a $20 stake on Team A:

Illustrative prices, not current offers. Our calculations use total return = stake × decimal odds; profit = total return − stake.

The extra $10 profit on the regulation selection comes with a narrower winning condition. If Team A wins during regulation, both selections win. If regulation ends tied and Team A wins in overtime, only its full-game moneyline wins.

If Team A loses after a regulation tie, both Team A selections lose. The three-way tie selection would already have won, regardless of which team eventually won the game.

• Profit excludes your original stake.
• Total return includes your original stake.
• A losing selection returns nothing under ordinary win-or-lose settlement.

For the related question “What does +200 moneyline mean?”, +200 is a fixed American-format example: a $100 winning stake earns $200 profit and returns $300 altogether. That number describes the payout. It does not tell you whether the market includes overtime.

When does three-way betting offer better value than the moneyline?

Three-way betting offers better value only when its price compensates for the smaller set of winning outcomes. Confidence that a team will win eventually is not the same as confidence that it will lead after regulation.

Using the hypothetical decimal prices above, the break-even probability is 1 ÷ decimal odds:

• At decimal 1.80, a full-game selection needs to win about 55.6% of the time to break even.
• At decimal 2.30, a regulation selection needs to win about 43.5% of the time to break even.

These are our calculations for ordinary bets without refunds or fees. They are thresholds implied by the prices, not measured chances for a particular team.

Suppose your own estimates give Team A a 58% chance of winning eventually but a 42% chance of winning in regulation. Those invented estimates would favour the moneyline at the example prices: 58% exceeds its threshold, while 42% falls below the regulation threshold.

Different estimates could favour regulation betting, both selections or neither. The useful comparison is each price against the probability of its own settlement condition.

Some bettors estimate regulation wins and ties separately. Others focus on full-game winners because that is the outcome they assess more confidently. Neither approach creates value automatically. The NHL bankroll guide explains how stake choices affect the consequences of being wrong.

What happens to a three-way NHL bet if the game goes to overtime?

A standard three-way regulation market is already decided before overtime starts: the tie selection wins and both team selections lose. An eventual win cannot rescue a regulation selection.

The practical mistake is comparing prices before comparing market labels. Two offers naming the same team may cover different results, so the larger payout may be for a different bet.

Before confirming a selection, check:

• Whether the market says full game, regulation or a particular period.
• Whether overtime and shootouts are included.
• Whether a tie is a selectable outcome.
• Whether the accepted bet slip matches the market you intended.

A label referring to one period does not mean the full regulation game. Likewise, an unfamiliar two-option market should not be assumed to include overtime solely because no tie price appears. Its settlement terms control the result.

For other market distinctions, the NHL betting guide connects winner bets with handicaps and totals.

Compare current hockey odds across betting platforms