Buying 4 or 10 usually costs less than placing them; placing 6 or 8 usually costs less than buying. The craps buy bets vs place bets comparison changes on 5 and 9: buying is cheaper with an exact 5% commission charged only on wins, but placing is cheaper when that fee applies to every resolved bet. Our craps rules guide explains the wider game.
Both bets back a selected number to appear before 7. Buying changes the payout and adds a fee; it does not improve the chance of winning.
What is the difference between craps buy bets and place bets?
A place bet pays a fixed amount below the mathematically fair payout. A buy bet pays that fair amount before a separate commission, also called the vig.
Learn the Odds describes the shared settlement rule: your selected number wins, 7 loses, and other totals leave the bet unresolved. The comparison below assumes the bet is active and stays active until one of those deciding totals appears.
| Selected number | Place profit | Buy profit before commission | Chance of winning before 7 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4 or 10 | $9 per $5 | $10 per $5 | 1/3 |
| 5 or 9 | $7 per $5 | $7.50 per $5 | 2/5 |
| 6 or 8 | $7 per $6 | $7.20 per $6 | 5/11 |
Payout rules: Learn the Odds. Probabilities: OddsGuru calculations from two independent fair six-sided dice. Profit excludes the returned stake; amounts illustrate payout ratios before rounding.
There are three dice combinations making 4, four making 5 and five making 6, compared with six making 7. The corresponding higher numbers have the same counts. Ignoring rolls that settle neither side gives the probabilities above.
True odds do not mean a commission-free bet. They describe the payout before the casino deducts its fee. Our place-bet payout guide covers the smaller fixed payouts in more detail.
Is it better to buy or place numbers in craps?
With an exact 5% fee on the stake, buying wins the cost comparison on 4 and 10, placing wins on 6 and 8, and commission timing decides 5 and 9.
House edge means expected loss as a percentage of the amount committed. It describes a long-run average, not a prediction for one session.
| Number | Place house edge | Buy: fee charged upfront | Buy: fee only on wins |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4 or 10 | 6.67% | 4.76% | 1.67% |
| 5 or 9 | 4.00% | 4.76% | 2.00% |
| 6 or 8 | 1.52% | 4.76% | 2.27% |
OddsGuru derivations using the payouts and probabilities above, with an exact 5% stake-based commission and no rounding. Each calculation covers one resolved wager. Upfront-buy percentages use stake plus fee; other columns use stake alone.
The denominator matters. A $100 buy bet with a $5 upfront commission commits $105. Its expected loss is $5, so the quoted edge is $5 ÷ $105 = 4.76%. Relative to the $100 number bet alone, that cost is 5%.
Before commission, true-odds payouts have zero expected profit. An upfront fee therefore becomes the expected loss. When the fee applies only to wins, expected loss equals the fee multiplied by the winning probability.
For example, buying 5 with $100 and a win-only $5 fee produces an expected loss of 2/5 × $5 = $2, or 2%. Placing the same number costs 4% on average.
For place bets, the calculation is losing probability minus winning probability multiplied by profit per dollar. On 6, that is 6/11 − (5/11 × 7/6) = approximately 1.52%.
How does commission change a buy-bet payout?
Commission timing changes the losing result as well as the winning result. Comparing only what happens after a win misses that difference.
Consider a $20 bet on 4, with an exact $1 commission:
| Outcome | Place 4 | Buy 4: upfront fee | Buy 4: win-only fee |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4 arrives before 7 | $36 net profit | $39 net profit | $39 net profit |
| 7 arrives before 4 | $20 loss | $21 loss | $20 loss |
OddsGuru worked example using the stated payouts. Net profit deducts commission; the winning stake is returned separately.
The two buy versions produce the same net profit after a win. The win-only version saves the fee after a loss.
Fee rounding can change the comparison at smaller stakes. As a hypothetical example, a $10 buy bet charged a minimum $1 commission pays an effective fee of 10%, rather than 5%.
On 5, that win-only fee creates an expected loss of 2/5 × $1 = $0.40. Dividing by the $10 stake gives 4%, matching the standard place-bet edge. That is why “buy 5 and 9” needs a fee condition attached.
What should you check before buying a craps number?
Check the actual commission and net payout for your intended stake. A percentage alone does not tell you what happens when fees or payouts are rounded.
Before committing chips, establish:
- Whether commission applies upfront or only after a win.
- Whether the fee is calculated on the stake or another amount.
- Whether a minimum fee or rounding rule changes the charge.
- Whether the bet is active on the next roll.
- What happens to a paid fee if you remove an unresolved bet.
A larger stake may reduce the percentage impact of a minimum fee, but it also increases the amount you can lose. Use a stake that fits your craps session budget, rather than increasing it just to obtain a lower percentage cost.
Neither option becomes profitable under the fee assumptions above. If several numbers are active, a 7 loses all those wagers together; spreading chips across numbers does not make those losses independent. The craps rules guide explains how these bets sit alongside the rest of the table.
Compare current betting odds